Flame Marine reports

Flame Diagnostic

Flame Diagnostic is a full engine review for two-stroke marine engines. It reads the fuel, the oil and the engine's performance together and reports the condition of the whole engine.

Flame Diagnostic
Engines
MAN B&W, WinGD and UE two-stroke crosshead engines, including dual-fuel engines.
You send
  • Scavenge drain oil from every cylinder.
  • Fresh cylinder oil, fresh system oil and crankcase system oil.
  • Fuel from before the purifier and before the engine.
  • The Sample Submission Form and the engine performance data sheet, recorded while the samples are taken.
  • The bunker analysis for the fuel in use.
  • The shop test performance data, once.

Samples are taken at the vessel's usual load. The engine is not stopped.

Laboratory
ISO/IEC 17025 accredited, testing to ASTM, ISO and IP methods. Nothing is tested on board.
The report assesses
Performance, fuel oil, scavenge air, combustion, wear, water, system oil and cylinder oil feed. Each is marked normal, caution or action required for the engine, every cylinder and the turbochargers, beside the marks from the previous report.
You get back
  • Findings and a recommendation for each of the eight areas.
  • The reported power and cylinder oil feed rate checked against Flame Marine's own calculation.
  • Measured performance compared with the shop test curve at the same load.
  • Compression, maximum and mean indicated pressures and exhaust temperatures for each cylinder, as deviations from the engine mean.
  • Fuel on its way to the engine: water, cat fines, sodium, vanadium and sulphur before the purifier and before the engine, purifier efficiency, and fuel temperature against the viscosity the engine needs.
  • Drain oil results for every cylinder, as measured and corrected for dilution, with the trend over four samplings: total and magnetic iron, chromium, copper, tin, aluminium, vanadium, soot, dispersancy, BN, calcium, zinc, viscosity and water.
  • Total and magnetic iron against residual BN in the engine designer's zones.
  • The cylinder oil feed rate calculated from consumption and power, and a recommended change in g/kWh.
  • Liner and piston running hours and wear rates, from the vessel's records.
  • System oil condition.
Length
About 30 pages.
Dilution
Every drain oil result is corrected for the system oil, fuel and water in the sample and reported on a cylinder-oil basis. Dilution and Flame ADT.

Extracts

Inside a Flame Diagnostic report

From current reports for five different vessels, with names and dates removed.

Flame Diagnostic assessment for a six-cylinder engine: performance, fuel oil, scavenge air, cylinder condition, system oil and cylinder oil feed, each check marked for the engine, the cylinders or the turbocharger, with the finding in words
The assessment from one current report, redrawn for this page: every check, where it applies, and the finding in words.
Table comparing the Sample Submission Form with the Flame Marine calculation: power 4,510 kW in both, load 72.0 against 62.6 per cent of MCR, feed rate 1.04 against 1.35 g/kWh Engine load diagram with recommended, heavy and short-term operating areas and the engine's operating point marked in the recommended area
The reported load and feed rate checked against Flame Marine's calculation, and the operating point on the engine's load diagram.
Table comparing the shop test performance curve with measured averages for engine speed, fuel rack, compression pressure, maximum pressure, pressure rise, mean indicated pressure, turbocharger speed, scavenge pressure and exhaust temperature, with three conclusions on true load, torque and combustion timing
Measured averages against the shop test curve at the same load, and what the differences indicate.
Combustion finding: unstable combustion indicated on four units and cylinder lubricant burning on all units, three possible causes, and a recommendation to investigate
A combustion finding: the units concerned, the possible causes and the recommendation.
Cylinder oil feed finding: feed rate factor applied 0.37 g/kWh, basic setting 1 g/kWh, and a recommendation that the feed rate may be reduced by 0.05 g/kWh
Cylinder oil feed: the feed rate factor applied and the recommended change.
Bar charts of iron, soot, tin, copper, water and TBN for nine cylinders, each bar coloured green, amber or red by band
Wear findings: no influence of combustion on wear, minor abrasion between piston and liner on unit 8, elevated copper on unit 8 attributed to wearing-in after overhaul, no influence of water on wear
Wear evaluation for a nine-cylinder engine after dilution correction. Green is OK, amber warning, red alert.

In the engine

Freshly overhauled piston with clean, shiny surfaces
A newly overhauled piston.
The same piston with deposits on the lands and in the ring grooves
The same piston after 66 hours at a high feed rate with unstable combustion. Deposits are forming.
A clean piston after 30,000 running hours
A different piston after 30,000 hours without overhaul, feed rate optimised and combustion stable. The ring grooves are clean.